Why Kindness Isn’t a Weakness in Dog Training: Building Trust and Results Without Force

When it comes to training dogs, there is still a belief floating around that kindness is a soft option. That being nice, patient or encouraging makes you less effective. Or worse, that it gives your dog the upper hand. It is a view that lingers from the old days of dog training, when control was king and obedience was measured by compliance, no matter the cost.

But here is the truth. Kindness is not a weakness. It is a decision. It is not the easy route and it is not about letting dogs do whatever they like either. Kindness in dog training is about clarity. It is about teaching rather than intimidating. And in the long run, it works better.

Training is not about winning. It is about teaching

Let us be honest. There is often pressure to show your dog who is boss. This advice comes up quickly when someone is struggling with pulling on lead, ignoring recalls or reacting to other dogs. It can feel empowering to believe that all these things can be fixed by asserting dominance or using harsh corrections. But if that kind of pressure worked in the long term, we would not see so many behaviour problems repeating again and again.

Training is about communication. You are teaching your dog how to live in a world full of rules they did not create, with expectations they do not automatically understand. That takes patience. It takes repetition. And yes, it takes kindness. Not because your dog is fragile but because that is how real learning sticks.

Fear might get results. But not the kind you want

There is no question that using punishment can stop a behaviour in the short term. If you shout at a dog who is jumping up, they might hesitate next time. If you yank on a lead when they lunge, they might pause. But that is not learning. That is fear.

Fear does not teach your dog what to do. It just teaches them what not to do around you. That might sound like it is enough, but what it really creates is confusion, anxiety and distance. Dogs trained through fear may comply, but not with confidence. They are not making better choices because they understand. They are avoiding punishment.

And let us not forget. A scared dog can also be unpredictable. Suppressed behaviour can simmer underneath the surface and come out more explosively later on. That is not a risk worth taking.

Kindness is clarity. Not indulgence

There is a myth that training with kindness means letting your dog get away with things. That there are no boundaries, no structure, no expectations. But that could not be further from the truth.

Kind training is structured. It is full of repetition, rewards, timing and clarity. It is not chaotic or permissive. Instead, it is about setting your dog up to get it right. That means creating situations where they can succeed, reinforcing those successes and gradually building up the difficulty.

This kind of approach builds real confidence. Dogs become more focused, more willing to try and more capable of handling distractions because they trust that the path to success is clear.

Trust is the foundation of everything

Whether you have a new puppy or an older rescue, your relationship with your dog starts with trust. Trust that you will meet their needs, that you will listen when they are uncomfortable and that you will guide them in a way that feels safe.

If training breaks that trust, everything becomes harder. Walking, grooming, vet visits, recall, socialising. All of it. A dog who trusts you can handle being shown new things. A dog who does not will avoid, shut down or push back.

Trust is not earned through control. It is earned through consistency and predictability. If your dog knows what to expect from you, they will feel safe enough to take direction. And when they feel safe, real learning can happen.

Results come faster than you think

Some people worry that kind training is slow. That it takes too long or that it only works for certain types of dogs. But in practice, the opposite is often true. When a dog understands what you want and feels safe enough to try, the results can be surprisingly quick.

You will often see faster progress not because the dog is being pushed harder, but because the learning is clearer and less stressful. They are thinking, not just reacting. And because there is less emotional fallout, the behaviour tends to stick.

Consistency and kindness are not in competition. In fact, they are the perfect pairing. Be clear, be fair, be patient and you will see just how effective that can be.

It is not about being soft. It is about being smart

Using kind methods does not mean you are not being assertive or taking control of the situation. It means you are choosing to be effective without intimidation. You are leading, not overpowering. You are teaching, not correcting after the fact.

That is not weakness. That is skill. That is patience. That is emotional maturity, from both trainer and dog.

Dogs are not looking for a boss. They are looking for someone they can understand and follow. Someone who makes them feel safe enough to try, fail and try again. That is what good training creates.

You will not always get it right. And that is OK

Here is a dose of reality. Kind training does not mean you are going to handle every situation perfectly. There will be moments when you feel frustrated, when your dog does not respond how you expected or when progress feels slow.

What matters is what you do next. Do you lean into punishment and pressure or do you pause, reflect and choose a better route forward? Mistakes are part of the process, for both you and your dog.

Kindness is not just for your dog. It is also for you. Give yourself permission to learn, adapt and grow. That is what makes you a better teacher and ultimately, a better partner for your dog.

Real life examples say it all

We have seen it again and again. Dogs who came to us overwhelmed, shut down or overly reactive and slowly began to change once they felt safe.

Like the rescue who hid under the table at every noise, who slowly began approaching people on her own once she realised no one was going to force her. Or the adolescent lab who could not walk more than two minutes without lunging at everything, now calmly navigating busy parks because his people worked with his emotions, not against them.

These were not quick fixes. They were not perfect. But they were real. And they lasted.

There is a shift happening in dog training

We are at a turning point where more people than ever are asking better questions. Not just how to train, but why. Not just how to get results, but how to get results that last and feel good on both sides of the lead.

Kindness is no longer seen as a novelty or a niche option. It is fast becoming the gold standard. And rightly so.

So if you are choosing to train with kindness, you are not being soft. You are choosing to connect. To teach. To lead in a way that makes your dog want to follow. That is not weakness. It is the strongest approach there is.

If there is one thing to take away, it is this

Kindness in dog training does not mean anything goes. It means everything matters. How you teach, how you respond, how your dog feels. And when all of that is in place, the results speak for themselves.

💬 Want Personal Help with Your Dog?

Book a 15-minute virtual consultation via Microsoft Teams for just €15.

In this one-on-one session, we’ll talk through your dog’s behaviour and see if ongoing support is the right fit.  💡 If you decide to book a full session or package, your €15 fee is fully refunded.   It’s a no-pressure way to get expert advice and take the first step toward a calmer, happier dog.

Curious about what Paws Academy has to offer? Have a look at our online training hub and see what might work for you and your dog.