How Selective Breeding Has Changed Dogs For Better And Worse

We all know dogs did not just arrive in our homes looking the way they do now. That perfectly squishy face, that tiny body with oversized eyes or those long legs built to run, none of it is down to chance. The dogs we live with today are the result of thousands of years of human influence. Selective breeding, while responsible for some of the things we love most about our dogs, has also led to some serious downsides.

Let’s take a look at how selective breeding has changed dogs, for better and for worse.

The Origins of Selective Breeding

Selective breeding is not a modern concept. Humans have been shaping the dog for over fifteen thousand years. It started with early partnerships between humans and wolves. Over time, people noticed which animals were better at certain tasks, hunting, guarding or herding, and started breeding those individuals. What began as a practical way to get the job done turned into something far bigger.

By the Victorian era, breeding dogs became less about what they could do and more about how they looked. This is where the trouble really began. Kennel clubs and breed standards were created, and dogs were bred to meet strict physical ideals. Behaviour and health started taking a back seat.

The Upside. Purpose-Bred Dogs That Help Humans

Let’s give credit where it is due. Selective breeding has created some incredibly capable working dogs. Border Collies, bred for intelligence and stamina, are still among the best herders in the world. Bloodhounds, with their unbelievable noses, are used in search and rescue. Labradors, known for their gentle nature and trainability, remain the top choice for assistance dogs.

When breeding is done with purpose and welfare in mind, the result is often a dog who is physically and mentally well-suited to the job. Many of these dogs thrive when given tasks to do and can have long, healthy lives.

We also would not have the wide variety of dog personalities and energy levels we do without selective breeding. Want a laid-back dog for a quiet home? There is a breed for that. Need a confident, alert dog for farm work? There is one for that too.

The Downside. Health and Behaviour Issues That Should Not Exist

Unfortunately, the story does not end there. For every dog bred with care and intention, there are many who have paid the price for human preferences. Selective breeding, especially when done carelessly or to chase appearance, has introduced a host of health problems.

Take the Bulldog. Once an athletic and agile animal, it is now often so exaggerated in structure that it struggles to breathe, walk or even give birth naturally. Its flattened face, a trait known as brachycephaly, is part of the breed standard, yet it causes lifelong respiratory distress.

Dachshunds were bred for their long bodies to help them hunt badgers. But that exaggerated length and short-legged design now leads to spinal problems. Intervertebral disc disease is common and can leave these dogs in serious pain or even paralysed.

And it is not just physical health. Behavioural problems are on the rise too. When breeders prioritise looks over temperament, we can end up with dogs who are reactive, anxious or difficult to train. It is not fair on the dog, and it is certainly not fair on the owner who may not be prepared for such challenges.

The Popularity Problem

Social media and television have a lot to answer for. Flat-faced breeds like Pugs and French Bulldogs have exploded in popularity, despite their health issues being well documented. Why? Because they are seen as cute.

The trouble is, demand drives supply. When a breed becomes fashionable, irresponsible breeders seize the opportunity. Puppies are bred without health checks, often in poor conditions, and sold to unsuspecting buyers. The results can be heartbreaking, both emotionally and financially.

Many people do not realise the full implications until it is too late. That snorty breathing or constant scratching might seem normal for the breed, but it should not be. It is a sign that the dog is uncomfortable or in pain. We have normalised suffering in the name of aesthetics.

The Pressure of Breed Standards

Breed standards, which are supposed to guide responsible breeding, often reinforce extreme traits. Judges at dog shows reward dogs that meet these visual ideals, even if it compromises function. For example, German Shepherds are frequently bred with severely sloping backs because that is what wins in the ring. Yet it often results in hip and spine problems.

The standards were never meant to promote dysfunction. But over time, what is typical for a breed has shifted further and further from what is natural or healthy.

Some kennel clubs are trying to address this. There have been moves to update breed standards to put more emphasis on health. But change is slow, and there is still a long way to go.

What Can Be Done?

We cannot undo the past, but we can make better decisions moving forward. Ethical breeding is the way forward, where dogs are bred with health, temperament and function in mind, not just looks. Reputable breeders will carry out health testing, socialise their puppies properly and be transparent about any breed-related issues.

There is also a growing movement around crossbreeding or outcrossing, introducing new bloodlines to reduce inherited diseases. For example, crossing Cavaliers with healthier breeds to try and combat the heart conditions that plague them.

That said, crossbreeds are not automatically healthier. Designer dogs like Cockapoos or Cavachons can still inherit problems from both sides if their parents are not screened properly. It comes down to who is doing the breeding, not just what is being bred.

Rethinking What We Value

One of the most powerful things we can do as owners is challenge the idea of what makes a dog desirable. Does it really matter if your dog’s ears are not the perfect shape? Or that their legs are a bit longer than what the standard says? What matters is how that dog lives, whether they can breathe freely, run comfortably and enjoy their life.

We need to be more critical of the way dogs are presented online and in the media. If you see a dog that looks adorable but cannot go for a decent walk without struggling for air, that is not cute, it is concerning.

Choose substance over style. If you are getting a dog, ask questions. Insist on health testing. Meet the parents if you can. Look at the whole dog, not just their appearance.

The Role of Rescue and Rehoming

Selective breeding has created another unfortunate side effect, overpopulation of certain breeds in rescues. When the fashion dies down or health issues become overwhelming, many owners give up their dogs.

Rescue centres are full of dogs who have been let down by breeding and buying trends. But they are also full of brilliant dogs who just need a fresh start. If you are considering a dog, do not overlook adoption. You might find a healthier and happier companion without encouraging problematic breeding practices.

In Summary

Selective breeding has given us dogs that can herd sheep, guide people with vision loss and alert humans to danger. But it has also given us dogs that cannot breathe properly, cannot give birth without surgery or suffer with constant pain, all because of how they look.

As dog lovers, we owe it to them to do better. We need to value their health and well-being above image. Whether you are a breeder, a buyer or just someone who loves dogs, that responsibility is shared.

The good news is that change is possible. Awareness is growing, and more people are questioning the status quo. The more informed choices we make, the better the future will be for the dogs we care so much about.

💬 Want Personal Help with Your Dog?

Book a 15-minute virtual consultation via Microsoft Teams for just €15.

In this one-on-one session, we’ll talk through your dog’s behaviour and see if ongoing support is the right fit.  💡 If you decide to book a full session or package, your €15 fee is fully refunded.   It’s a no-pressure way to get expert advice and take the first step toward a calmer, happier dog.

Curious about what Paws Academy has to offer? Have a look at our online training hub and see what might work for you and your dog.